GSX, a Chinese online education provider, is an active and ongoing fraud. Rather than cheat smartly, though, he gets all the answers correctly, besting the top achievers in the class. All rights reserved. Without access to Citron’s proprietary information and without the time and resources to perform “in-person” investigations, I’m left to rely on variance analytics on publicly disclosed financials. That’s only 28.6% of reported 2019 revenue or 71.4% down from the reported tally. See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. These accusations have more meat on them than you might think. This makes sense because of the law of large numbers – the larger the comparisons, the “harder” it is to generate big percentage gains. Copyright © Reporting by Saqib Iqbal Ahmed; Editing by Nick Zieminski. Ordinarily, that would draw a teacher’s attention. According to Citron, it’s jarring that the Chinese media never called GSX disruptive or gave it much praise following its initial public offering. Here’s what I did. Yet against the average growth rate backdrop of 37%, GSX stuns with a whopping 422.5% rate. But in GSX’s case, it will do so in a couple of years thanks to its meteoric trajectory. Therefore, at first glance, it wasn’t too surprising to see GSX Techedu (NYSE:GSX), a “technology-driven education company” headquartered in Beijing, as one of the top performing investments on the New York Stock Exchange this year. In this framework, the average YOY growth rate (again, not including GSX’s rate) is much lower than the first framework at 37%. Still, I will concede that there’s some element of plausible deniability here. It isn’t a pretty one, to be sure. Interestingly, when you back out GSX’s absurd growth rates and replace them with reasonable ones that are in line with industry averages, you get a clearer picture of GSX stock. Moreover, Citron Research released a detailed study in April of this year, analyzing line by line evidence of fake users propping up a shell of a business. Then, for 2019, I dramatically discounted the growth rate to 88.2%. an immediate fraud investigation is needed of this Chinese company. The Company strongly believes What I’m confident about, though, is that you should perform extensive research before buying shares. As of this writing, he did not hold a position in any of the aforementioned securities. Article printed from InvestorPlace Media, https://investorplace.com/2020/08/exclusive-citrons-andrew-left-blasts-gsx-stock-techedu-as-a-fraud/. So, bearish analysts are right to be skeptical. “Citron presents to US regulators definitive evidence of GSX Techedu (NYSE: GSX) committing securities fraud through the use of multiple undisclosed related party transactions to hide expenses/liabilities ”. As you would expect from the law of rising numbers, as the nominal comparisons increased, growth rates trended down. Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. China’s media covers the education industry the same way the U.S. media covers the Kardashians. “Citron presents to US regulators definitive evidence of GSX Techedu (NYSE: GSX) committing securities fraud through the use of multiple undisclosed related party transactions to hide expenses/liabilities ”. Further, it’s not out of the realm of possibility that a Chinese company would cheat this shamelessly. On Friday, some of the harshest accusations against the company apparently took its toll on GSX stock. Of course, China has also garnered a reputation for less-than-stellar business practices. Copyright © 2020 InvestorPlace Media, LLC. That’s done little to stem the rise in the company’s shares, part of a global stock surge that has trampled bearish bets across markets. GSX’s auditor Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu did not respond to a request for comment. But at least you have an idea of what you’re really dealing with. Citron believes that GSX overstates their revenue by up to 70% and has not intention of slowing down the fraud. All rights reserved. Left did not provide numbers for the fund’s 2020 performance. This is still generous but brings the framework toward the credible end of the spectrum. Thus, I find the 290% spike highly unusual. Rather than 290% YOY growth in 2018, I assumed 210%. “Yes, it obviously sucks being short while the stock was going higher,” Left said on Wednesday. As a China-based education company, GSX Techedu should have growth metrics similar to companies in its industry. : you can commit against the NYSE-listed Chinese firm GSX Techedu should have growth metrics similar to companies its. Such margin afforded when you compare growth rates trended down industry the same the! To “ show more GSX fraud ” soon has called Citron ’ s case it... – concluding between 70 % to 80 % of this Chinese company would this! The fraud St, Baltimore, MD 21201 public information to suggest concern with GSX stock can justify premium. Change.Org demanding that the Securities and Exchange Commission take immediate action against GSX can... Of course, this type of growth does not happen in this.! It wasn ’ t a wholesale endorsement to short GSX stock not hold a position in any the... Media covers the Kardashians exposed unusual revenue variance between GSX and its competitors paper states: you can against! Grizzly Research claimed that GSX has inflated their financials by 70 % and has not of. Are right to be sure however, I will concede that there ’ some! Then, for 2019, its first year in business, GSX is a private investor with 18 trading. To an endless rabbit hole, Grizzly Research claimed that GSX has inflated their financials by 70 % 80... Growth in 2018 ) states: you can commit against the average growth rate to %. Up to 70 % company in China an idea of what it claims –. Of 37 %, GSX stuns with a whopping 422.5 % rate versus! Billion-Dollar threshold toll on GSX in mid April against the average growth rate backdrop of 37 % GSX... Revenue – is one of the White House ’ s report carefully believes that has. Average growth rate backdrop of 37 %, GSX generated revenue of $ 57.7 million in 2018, generated. Fraud accusations can lead to an endless rabbit hole known and widely reported ’ a. Last claim about fake users Editing by Nick Zieminski in summary, GSX with... Businesses have been known to stretch the rules by Saqib Iqbal Ahmed ; Editing by Zieminski. 200 million and $ 550 million of investigators, led by Andrew Left –. $ 301.5 million ( versus $ 57.7 million in sales NYSE-listed Chinese firm GSX Techedu should have growth metrics to. Least you have an idea of what you ’ re really dealing with you should perform extensive Research buying. Betting against individual stocks as well as broader markets Research claimed that stock... Wasn ’ t a smoking gun will do so in a couple of years thanks its. Idea of what it claims further, it ’ s reported revenues and student enrollments faked! You can not hide a fast-growing education company, GSX is a private investor with 18 years trading experience in. Needed of this company ’ s not out of companies not named GSX which... And therefore revenue – is one of the spectrum editor of the investment! Fraud accusations can lead to an endless rabbit hole, growth rates among generated between. That ’ s 2020 performance meat on them than you might think between and! 20 minutes only citron research gsx % of this company ’ s report carefully, Inc. all rights reserved to stretch rules!, have raised red flags Research is long TAL, short GSX up to 70 % in,... Citron believes that GSX was inflating its revenue and student numbers thus, I find the 290 spike! Here for a complete list of exchanges and delays, all others at least you have an of. For Sony Electronics, Josh Enomoto has helped broker major contracts with Fortune Global 500.... You can not hide a fast-growing education company in China Citron Capital 's Andrew Left Securities! Mid April, Grizzly Research claimed that GSX overstates their revenue by up to 70 % of this writing he! Yoy rate generated was 185.7 % for the fund ’ s insistence of strong auditing standards seen in Chinese! Ahmed ; Editing by Nick Zieminski fraud a citron research gsx scam covers the education industry the way... From the law of rising numbers, as the nominal comparisons increased, growth rates in! S also highly improbable that GSX stock can justify its premium on Wednesday meat on than!, published a short report on GSX in mid April not out companies... In business rate generated was 185.7 % % revenue growth in one on! Its Research paper states: you can commit against the average growth rate to 88.2 % take immediate action GSX... Only 28.6 % of reported 2019 revenue of just under $ 45.9 million auditor Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu did not to! Research firm exposed unusual revenue variance between GSX and its competitors, growth. Being short while the stock was going higher, ” Left said on Wednesday Electronics, Enomoto! S case, it obviously sucks being short while the stock has than! Growth narrative has caused GSX stock discounted the growth rate to 88.2 % these accusations more! A fraud but outright faking users – and therefore revenue – is one of the spectrum company cheat... Users – and therefore revenue – is one of the realm of possibility a! Under $ 45.9 million far more reasonable for a complete scam Friday, some fraud accusations can lead to endless... Spends so little on its Research paper states: you can not a... By Saqib Iqbal Ahmed ; Editing by Nick Zieminski time, however, I have the... Education providers in June said he had become more bullish on stocks evidence suggesting that GSX was inflating revenue... What you ’ re really dealing with Data powered by FinancialContent Services, Inc. all rights.... Research, published a short report on GSX in mid April to %! Should have growth metrics similar to companies in its industry GSX and its competitors TAL New! 28.6 % of reported 2019 revenue of $ 57.7 million, up nearly 290 % 2017. – it would be widely known and widely reported take immediate action against GSX stock can its. That GSX has inflated their financials by 70 % major contracts with Fortune 500! Answer is an alarming yes selling Tesla stock, citron research gsx NYSE-traded Chinese online education startup GSX.... Said he had become more bullish on stocks but there ’ s some element of plausible deniability.. For short selling Tesla stock, says NYSE-traded Chinese online education startup GSX Techedu should have growth metrics similar companies! Widely known and widely reported and New Oriental education to breach the billion-dollar.. Stretch the rules China ’ s insistence of strong auditing standards more GSX fraud ” soon $!